The Legend of a Buried Fortune

Our story begins in 1822 in Lynchburg, Virginia. A local innkeeper named Robert Morriss was entrusted with a locked iron box by a guest, a charismatic but enigmatic man named Thomas J. Beale. Beale, who had been leading a prospecting party in the West, claimed to have discovered an immense treasure. He and his men had buried it for safekeeping in a secret location in Bedford County, Virginia.

The box, he explained, contained papers that detailed the treasure’s location, its contents, and the rightful heirs. Beale promised to mail Morriss the key to the ciphers at a later date but then vanished, never to be seen or heard from again. True to his word, no key ever arrived.

For 23 years, Morriss kept the box unopened. Finally, in 1845, his curiosity won. He broke the lock and found several papers, including two letters written in plain English and three pages covered in blocks of numbers, from 1 to 1900. These were the now-infamous Beale Ciphers.

A Triptych of Secrecy

The three ciphers were purported to hold distinct pieces of the puzzle:

• Ciphertext 1: The longest of the three, said to describe the exact location of the vault. (Unsolved)
• Ciphertext 2: The shortest, detailing the contents of the treasure. (Solved)
• Ciphertext 3: A list of the names and residences of Beale’s partners, the treasure’s co-owners. (Unsolved)

After years of fruitless effort, Morriss passed the papers to a friend. This friend, later identified only as James B. Ward who published the story in an 1885 pamphlet, possessed a stroke of genius—or perhaps just incredible persistence. He correctly hypothesized that the ciphers were a book cipher, a cryptographic method where the key is a specific text.

The Declaration of Independence: An Unlikely Key

A book cipher is both elegantly simple and fiendishly complex. The encryptor chooses a text—any book, poem, or document—and uses it as a key. Each number in the ciphertext corresponds to a word in the key text. To decrypt the message, you simply take the first letter of the corresponding word.

The challenge, of course, is finding the correct key text. Ward tested countless books. The Bible? Shakespeare? Nothing worked. Then, he had a breakthrough. What document would an American adventurer, a man of liberty and patriotism, hold dear? He tried the United States Declaration of Independence.

And it worked. For Ciphertext 2, at least.

How it Worked: A Step-by-Step Decryption

Let’s look at the beginning of the second cipher. The numbers start with: 115, 73, 24, 807, 37, 52, 49, 17, 31, 62…

Using a standard version of the Declaration of Independence, the decryption process looks like this:

• The 115th word is “instituted”. The first letter is I.
• The 73rd word is “have”. The first letter is H.
• The 24th word is “been”. The first letter is B.
• The 807th word is “dug”. The first letter is D.
• The 37th word is “eighteen”. The first letter is E.

And so on. When fully decoded, Ciphertext 2 reveals a staggering inventory:

“I have deposited in the county of Bedford, about four miles from Buford’s, in an excavation or vault, six feet below the surface of the ground, the following articles, belonging jointly to the parties whose names are given in number three, herewith:

The first deposit consisted of ten hundred and fourteen pounds of gold, and thirty-eight hundred and twelve pounds of silver, deposited Nov. eighteen nineteen. The second was made Dec. eighteen twenty-one, and consisted of nineteen hundred and seven pounds of gold, and twelve hundred and eighty-eight of silver; also jewels, obtained in St. Louis in exchange to save transportation, and valued at thirteen thousand dollars.”

At today’s prices, the precious metals alone would be worth well over $60 million. The mystery was partially solved, but the most crucial piece—the location—remained locked away in Ciphertext 1.

The Unsolved Linguistic Puzzle

With one key found, you’d think the others would be easy. Just find two more documents, right? But it’s not that simple. Cryptographers and linguists have spent over a century trying every conceivable text—the Magna Carta, the Constitution, various books of the Bible, the works of Edgar Allan Poe (who had a known interest in cryptography and lived nearby)—all to no avail.

This raises fascinating linguistic and statistical questions:

• Varying Editions: Which version of a text did Beale use? Punctuation, spelling, and paragraph breaks can change the word count, rendering a modern version useless as a key.
• Custom Keys: Did Beale use a personal, unpublished document, like a diary or a letter? If so, the ciphers are mathematically unbreakable without it.
• Statistical Anomalies: When linguists analyze the number patterns in the unsolved ciphers, they find oddities. For instance, certain numbers that should appear based on English letter frequency (like those corresponding to the letter ‘e’) are absent. The distribution of numbers looks more random than one would expect from a natural language text, leading many to believe they are meaningless.

Hoax or History? The Debate Rages On

The linguistic evidence has fueled a fierce debate about the authenticity of the ciphers. Skeptics point to several red flags:

First, the entire story comes from the 1885 pamphlet published by James B. Ward, a man who conveniently profited from its sale. Historians have found no definitive proof that a “Thomas J. Beale” matching the description ever existed.

More damning, however, are the linguistic anachronisms within the “solved” text itself. The decrypted message from Cipher 2 contains words like “stampeding”, a term that linguistic research suggests did not enter common American English until the 1830s or 1840s—a full decade after Beale supposedly wrote the ciphers in 1822. Could Beale have been ahead of his time, or is this a slip-up from a 19th-century hoaxer?

Despite the powerful arguments for a hoax, the allure remains. The complexity is staggering for a simple fraud. Why create two intricate, seemingly unsolvable ciphers just to sell a 50-cent pamphlet? Why use a verifiable key for one, proving the method, only to make the others nonsensical?

Whether it’s a genuine map to a lost fortune or one of America’s most brilliant and enduring hoaxes, the Beale Ciphers stand as a monumental testament to the power of language as both a tool for communication and a means of concealment. It’s a reminder that sometimes, the greatest treasures aren’t buried in the ground, but hidden in plain sight, encoded in the very words we use every day.